About Me

Name: Bruce S. Ticker
Email: BTicker@comcast.net Biography
Loading...

Create Your Own Blog Find Other Townhall Blogs

Comments

Archives

Blog Roll

 

KYL/OBAMA WATCH: SCATTERED ISRAELI WORRIES

President Obama was tested during the past few weeks on his Israeli policies and generally passed.

Obama is fully aware that he walks a diplomatic tightrope each time he participates in Middle East issues. Obama and his designated diplomats certainly stepped carefully, particularly when Secretary of State Hillary Clinton visited Israel and its neighbors for the first time in her new capacity.

However, questions are raised over Clinton’s vague call for an expanded open border with Gaza; engagement with the Syrians; and the promise of $900,000 for Gaza and the West Bank. Also, Obama misstepped on his administration’s choice of Charles W. Freeman Jr. as chairman of the National Intelligence Council.

On the Republican side, Sen. Jon Kyl of Arizona exploited the Gaza war aftermath to play budget politics.

A Kyl/Obama Watch is fitting because many American Jews and other supporters of Israel question Obama’s commitment to Israel. The Republicans are not perfect, either, and Kyl gave us ammunition…not to mention a mercifully terse name…to represent his party and ideological pals on Middle East issues.

Clinton’s most disturbing statement, on March 4, opened the door for Israel to allow more than emergency aid to pass through the border into Gaza. She was quoted by the Associated Press as saying, “We want humanitarian aid to get into Gaza in sufficient amounts to alleviate the suffering of the people in Gaza.”

 

Most of us “want humanitarian aid to get into Gaza,” yet we also want Cpl. Gilad Shalit released after 33 months in captivity. The people of Gaza are lucky that Israel is allowing any aid at all to pass through the border. Shalit’s kidnapping and ongoing detention was an act of war, and Israel has every right to do whatever it deems necessary in seeking to retrieve Shalit. Why should Israel do anything for Gaza until Shalit returns?

And why didn’t Clinton mention that?

Israel and the United States may well benefit from talks with Syria as a result of Clinton’s announcement that two senior officials were sent to Syria to initiate talks with Syrian leaders. However, the natural price for any deals may be returning the Golan Heights to Syria. Would that be worth it? Many supporters of Israel do not think so.

That $900,000 - two-thirds for the West Bank and the rest for Gaza - presents the risk that Hamas might get its claws on some of that. It sounds like this money may never be used because Hamas will not consent to any conditions - namely, that they keep their hands off.

Freeman’s appointment was a blunder. I’m confused by the few Israel-related comments of his that I have read, but he already came with baggage that was heavy enough to abort his appointment.

On March 9, Sen. Kyl pressed for a vote on a amendment to Obama’s spending bill to prohibit any funds to relocate refugees from Gaza to America, the New York Times reported. Where did this come from? The bill never designated any money for that reason in the first place. The Times article noted that Kyl wanted to be certain and compel Democrats to vote on a sensitive issue.

Kyl also advocated for an amendment to prevent Gaza reconstruction money from being diverted to Hamas. Maybe it was helpful to make a point of that.

So far, no disastrous moves related to Israel on either side of the political divide. Let’s keep it that way.

 

Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (1) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive

HAMAS PSYCHOS

If ever there was a case of the inmates taking over the asylum…

The Palestinian Health Ministry accused Hamas of seizing control of a psychiatric hospital in Gaza in recent weeks and evicting the patients to transform it into a prison for Fatah supporters, according to Israeli media reports.

Israel-based reporter David Bedein informed readers of The Bulletin, an emerging conservative daily newspaper in Philadelphia, that Hamas has established a new command headquarters in a building in the yard of the hospital.

Surprised? I sure am. No, I’m not surprised that Hamas seized a psychiatric hospital, but that Gaza would have a facility aimed at treating mental illness in a terrain where sanity is deviant behavior.

No question that the Jewish people alone, not to mention Westerners in general, can be a neurotic bunch. Many Jews are products of dsyfunctional families, but the mental health of Jews and other Westerners is exceptional when compared to the Arab world.

Not only is it ironic that Hamas’s leaders are now gathered in a facility to treat mental illness, but this move offered a brief window of opportunity to resolve relations between Israel and its hostile neighbors.

Very simply, their presence in a psychiatric hospital could have been an opportunity for the Hamas leaders themselves to get treatment. Unfortunately, Hamas kicked out the medical staff. In addition, I have to wonder if a psychiatric hospital in Gaza genuinely measures up to the standards expected of your average mental health facility.

Think of it. If the medical professionals are recalled to the hospital, they could sit down with the Hamas leaders one at a time and help them process - don’t you love that word? - their feelings about themselves as they apply to Israel.

Let’s take one issue - another loveable word - at a time with advice of a therapist:

Those rocket attacks

Therapist: You have a deep need to act out. There is a lot of energy in you, and you might wish to consider redirecting those energies. Find another outlet. If you like to command troops, perhaps you can coach a soccer team. If you enjoy erecting missile launchers, maybe you can try building cars or homes.

Detention of Cpl. Gilad Shalit

Therapist: You have a consuming need for control. You are so obsessive about relationships that sometimes you cannot let go. The very idea of his release makes you feel threatened. There are times when you must let go.

Alliance with Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad

Therapist: That’s easy. Peer pressure. It is so tempting to fall in with the wrong crowd in your neighborhood. I know it is hard, but you must be careful to choose the right kind of friends if you hope to improve your life. Not to mention staying alive.

Since this guy is receiving counseling, I wonder what the therapist would say about such internal cultural habits as honor killings and blood feuds.

Therapist: Oh, no. We cannot touch such issues. We have no right to make judgments about their cultural traditions. That would be…insensitive.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Email ItEmail It | Print ItPrint It | CommentsComments (0) | TrackbacksTrackbacks (0) | Flag as offensiveFlag as Offensive
« Previous1Next »